Highest Rated Comments


mrpulp13 karma

I am also a beginner player. But the thing I have started to realize is that the game isn't about capturing individual stones or groups, or close fighting. It's much more about building the wider framework that will (in theory) support you when you eventually get into a fight. I.e. placing a stone in another place across the board helps you in fights somewhere that doesn't seem apparent at the get go.

In this it is fascinating because it really is equivalent to military strategy, where you don't just want to win a battle but create an environment which enables wider victory.

mrpulp10 karma

I have a question that is fairly subjective but an important one, about the accessibility of Go to new players: I've been interested in Go for a while, but never really got around to learning until the AlphaGo matches. In part I was motivated to learn because I wanted to understand what was going on - and Michael Redmond's commentary was incredibly lucid and clear. However I want to ask about why Go may be hard for new players to grasp, and if it is any more difficult than games it is often compared to, like Chess.

I've played Chess since I was a kid, but I have always felt when trying to learn Go that it is much more difficult. Is it inherently a more difficult game to learn than Chess? My sense is that it is - if only because it is more abstract and it's harder to tell why your bad move is a mistake. For instance, in Chess you can see that you put your Queen in danger, which is clearly your most powerful piece. There are force moves and sequences in Chess too, but in Go I've found that it's hard to see what's coming when playing against a stronger player - I keep making "mistake" moves, which are tough to see are mistakes until 4-5 moves later.

Does this make Go a less accessible game for new players? How can this be mitigated?

mrpulp6 karma

What are good opportunities for people to play go when there aren't a lot of local players? I.e. if you don't live in Seattle. Is the best option just to play online?

mrpulp3 karma

So how do feel about not being added as a "Great Musician" in Civ V? I think it's deserved...

mrpulp2 karma

Some people think manufacturing jobs are "coming back." But clearly - they aren't. Because even if companies build new plants in the US they will be highly automated and require workers with advanced technical knowledge. But even Democrats talk as if this isn't the future. Why do you think politicians - on both sides of the aisle- are unable to address the complex and nuanced issues of the future of manufacturing? Why do people still pander to those who think that low skill, high paying manufacturing has Amy future whatsoever?

Edit. Spelling. Stupid auto cores to