Highest Rated Comments


jjbeard882 karma

I’m still a bit mixed on the Stoics stance on retaliation/ defense against physical injuries. I know the stories of Cato being hit in a Roman bath and brushing off the incident and Socrates doing the same when batted on the ear. Could you further elaborate on the Stoic perspective on this matter?? Thanks

jjbeard882 karma

Your responses have been really valuable. Again, appreciate you taking the time for this Q&A.

jjbeard882 karma

Perfect, really appreciate your responses. I have one more thing to ask you. I recently read “The Practicing Stoic” by Ward Fansworth and your review of his book. What really struck me was his suggestion that Stoicism being the philosophy of a thousand trials; The wiseman who has lived for so long that he’s gained equanimity from the many years of experiencing the trials of life. This idea really gave me clarity and better understanding of Stoicism. I wanted to know your opinion on the idea of Stoicism being a short cut and/or compensation of the shortness of time and if any of the Stoics viewed it in this way. I feel my question, yet again, is vague, so I apologize, in advance.

jjbeard882 karma

Thank you, Donald, actually your response was helpful. To clarify, though, I just wanted to know, if for example, you were punched in the face how would the stoic handle that situation.