inscrutablerudy

we know from Genesis that everything God created was good. God, being a good God, only creates good things – even the things in the universe which might appear to be inherently evil (e.g. cancer, poison, etc.) are not. This is because at the very least they have the characteristic of existence, and to exist is better than to not exist, so anything that does exist must be good to some degree

This is an interesting personal story and you have the right to your beliefs. I don't think your logical arguments are at all sound, but logical arguments aren't necessary to faith.

Here in the quoted paragraph you are making a great case for the moral relativism that you claim made you reject atheism.

If everything that God does is good, how can you condemn any choice made by anyone?