Highest Rated Comments

amc2200422 karma

Hey Alec, thanks for the AMA! How did you get into podcasting, and what was the biggest challenge for you in suddenly being on the other side of the interview chair? Did you get any particularly helpful tips from journalists that you've gotten to know over the years?

amc2200420 karma

What do you make of the fact that last month Springer Publishing released a tool that can detect SCIgen papers? Is this a good thing for publishers, or, as Slate suggests, "a tacit admission that even at the most reputable publishing houses, some peer-reviewed journals are incapable of providing even the most minimally competent peer review"?

amc2200415 karma

Could we not just acknowledge that men feel like they're being devalued and figure out a way to alleviate that stress

As a man who works in computer science, I think this sort of sentiment is exactly what frustrates women in the field. Can we "acknowledge that men feel like they're being devalued"? Umm, sure, I guess. But I think we need to pretty quickly move past that, because all suffering is not created equal, and men in general have not had anywhere near the same barriers to entry as women in terms of moving up in the field of science. Think about what it would be like to be a female grad student in u/vanderBoffin's example above - seeing that the playing field is level with your peers, but not with your mentors who occupy roles that you someday want to reach.

amc2200410 karma

Is a hotdog a sandwich?

amc220047 karma

Google search top American inventors. The first 20 inventors only 1 of them is white.

Yeah, that's just not true; 8 of them are. You don't need to exaggerate to get your point across.