SarahRyley12 karma2016-04-27 18:23:54 UTC
I'm surprised that you would say you think the NYPD has done well in implementing the law, since you have said you don't agree with how they are using it against businesses for alcohol violations (58% of business cases); have raised questions about some of its other undercover operations and subsequent nuisance actions, for example of massage parlors; and have said you don't agree with it being used against families (44% of all cases are residential).
View HistoryShare Link
SarahRyley6 karma2016-04-27 18:57:46 UTC
I think it's interesting that the law was enacted in the 1970s, before the 1993 Supreme Court ruling that found the government may not seize a home suspected of being involved in drug activity (via civil forfeiture) without notice or a hearing:
How do you think this ruling would apply to nuisance abatement?
SarahRyley4 karma2016-04-27 18:33:00 UTC
But what about to justify the ex parte order? Do you think the city should be required to show more recent incidents than one year ago in order to justify going in and closing a location on an emergency basis before the occupants have had the opportunity to come to court? A good example of this is the woman whose family was kicked out of their home for four days on an ex parte order over drug allegations that were 10 months old. Serious allegations, but they were so old that the offending tenants had moved out seven months before the NYPD got its order. What safeguards do you think should be in place to protect against this happening? And do you think those safeguards should be written into the law, or on a prosecutorial discretion (honor system) basis?
SarahRyley4 karma2016-04-27 18:45:58 UTC
I think the question is, should there be more written into the law to ensure these factors are addressed?
SarahRyley3 karma2016-04-27 18:07:37 UTC
City Council is considering introducing a bill that would reduce the time period the city has to request such an order -- from a year to perhaps 60 or 90 days -- and possibly to tighten the evidentiary standards.
Copyright © 2014 BestofAMA.com, All rights reserved.
reddit has not approved or endorsed BestofAMA, reddit design elements are trademarks of reddit inc.