RandomNerdGeek
Highest Rated Comments
RandomNerdGeek41 karma
Here's a summary of the questions and answers (sorted by top):
Part 1
Part 2
Question | Answer |
---|---|
Could there be Martian life in the water since it's only there at certain times of the year? What might happen to the life when the water disappears? | It's possible. We know of forms of life that hibernate during dry seasons on Earth. The water that we're seeing within the RSL (the seasonal dark streaks that we're seeing on slopes on Mars) is salty. Salty water could be harmful to life. |
It was mentioned that there's life on Mars in the form of microbes on the machinery. Is it possible that these microbes sent by us could harm Martian life? | We don't know what Earth life could do to any potential life on other worlds. That's why we try to clean our spacecraft very carefully. -- LT |
What's the next step? | The next step is to look for more locations where brine flows may occur. We have covered 3% of Mars at resolutions high enough to see these features. -RZ |
What are some examples of microbes that could be living on the rover that you are concerned with infecting the surface of Mars? | These features are on steep slopes, so our present rovers would not be able to climb up to them. Because liquid water appears to be present, these regions are considered special regions where we have to take extra precautions to prevent contamination by earth life. Our current rovers have not been sterilized to the degree needed to go to an area where liquid water may be present. -RZ |
If the rovers haven't been properly sterilized already, will this throw doubt upon any possible future discovery of Mars-based microbes living in or near the water? Wouldn't detractors be able to claim that they are microbes that somehow survived from Earth? | The rovers have been sterilized for their particular landing sites where there's been no evidence of present day liquid water. To go to the RSL rovers will be required to be sterilized to a higher level. We also take samples of microbes that might be on the spacecraft before they're launched, so we can compare with any future discoveries. -RZ |
Could you explain why you can't go near the water? Is it for fear of harming the rover? Or contaminating the water? | It's both. The dark streaks are on slopes that are too steep for our present rovers. Also, we want to be careful to not introduce Earth bugs into an environment that may have liquid water. -RZ |
How long into the future do you think it will be before we can realistically think about sending humans to Mars? | Presently, NASA is looking into the possibility of sending humans to the vicinity of Mars in the early 2030s. In this scenario, the earliest humans to the surface would be in the late 2030s. -RZ |
What quantity of water are we talking about? what volume? | We think this is a very small amount of water -- maybe just enough to wet the top layer of the surface of Mars. The streaks are ~4-5 meters wide and ~200-300 meters long. -- LT |
How much liquid water are we talking about? Like.. tap water leaking when you don't close the valve tight enough, or Niagara falls? | Tap water leaking. -RZ |
It was shown back in 2011 that salt water flows may be a seasonal occurrence. What was the final proof for the team that this was happening, and what was your initial reaction to the data? | With MRO, we were able to observe a few of these sites at various points within the Mars year, and again the next year. Over time, we saw that the streaks darkened and lengthened during the warm season and faded during the cold season. A benefit of having MRO lasting so long is that we're able to see changes and patterns over time. My reaction? This is all very exciting! The closer we look at Mars, the more interesting it gets. -- LT |
Is NASA now considering putting a man on Mars to get more data on this or can we find all the information without having a man/woman on Mars? | The basic answer is yes, NASA is planning to send humans to Mars in the 2030s. It's always helpful to have more information before sending them, and that's why our robotic explorers are so important. -- LT |
Do any of the space scientists at NASA write poetry/do art? If their art is inspired by their scientific work, can you please share it with us? | Absolutely. It takes all kinds of creative minds to do science and engineering that no one has ever done before. Among our mission teams, you'll find actors, musicians, sculptors, painters -- the list goes on. For visual artists, two individuals who spring to mind are Bill Hartmann and Dan Goods. -- SLS |
Is there any evidence of evaporation happening on Mars? And do you know where this water came from? | Is there any evidence of evaporation happening on mars? And do you know where this water came from? |
What does this mean in regards to possible life? | We think liquid water is essential for life (at least as we know it.) That does not mean that life is there; but, it's a good place to look. -RZ |
If the Mars rover were to travel to the site of the briny water, what would be the scientific procedure for determining if that water supports life? | The Curiosity rover does not have life detection instruments. It would look for confirmation that liquid water was present and how long during the day it was liquid. -RZ |
What would be the procedure if life is found on Mars? WOuld the public be made aware? Who gets told first? | Information flows to the public very quickly. If one of our missions here at JPL detected life, we'd notify NASA headquarters immediately, who would then follow procedures to notify the US government and the public. -- SLS |
In the articles I've read so far, the water is referred to as "briny" and that it's more fluid than it is water. What does that mean? Would this be something theoretically possible to drink or grow things with? Or would this be the kind of thing that would need purification before it could be used? | The salts in the water appear to be perchlorates, so I wouldn't want to drink the water. To be a future resource for humans, you would want to remove the salts. -RZ |
This may be a bit far-future looking, but does the fact that we know liquid flowing water exists mean anything for terraforming Mars in the future? | Think of this as a "seep" not a flow. We have not seen flowing water on the surface. We see something that darkens the soil, which may be just a wetting action but still involves (briny) liquid. -RZ |
Given the seasonal nature of today's discovery, does this suggest that their is a hydrologic cycle on Mars? | There is a hydrologic cycle on Mars, but typically it involves vapor going to ice (frost) or ice going to vapor. There is no rain in Mars today, but there may have been very early in its history. -RZ |
Scale of 1-10, how excited does this make you guys? Is this a huge deal for the scientific community? | This is super exciting! It is an important discovery because it is evidence that supports our hypothesis that the RSL (seasonal dark streaks that appear to flow in the warm season) are flowing briny (salty) water. --LT |
How close is the rover to the water? Will you be able to get close enough to get pictures without contamination? | There are no confirmed brine flows (RSL) near Curiosity nor Opportunity. There are in Gale Crater some interesting slope streaks but they are several km away from the Curiosity's present path. -RZ |
What do you say to those who would argue we already had proof with the ice caps? Obviously, they're full of water. Don't they melt periodically? | The ice caps freeze and sublime (solid to vapor.) The RSL water stays liquid because it has salts in it. Yes, we know there's water on Mars. We're looking for where it stays liquid for an extended period of time. -RZ |
What was the hardest technical challenge you faced on this project? What was the hardest nontechnical (political, cultural, legal, emotional &c) challenge? | The features that darken and fade as temperatures get warmer and then colder are long but narrow. The difficulty was to get enough resolution from our orbiter instruments to first detect, and then characterize what these features are. Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter (MRO) can do that with its HiRISE camera and CRISM Mineral Mapper. -RZ |
Why should the average joe care about this? What does this mean for science and space exploration? | Liquid water, even if very salty, is still a good place to look for life forms. We don't know how robust martian life (if it exists) could be. Also, water in any form is a resource that future missions could exploit. -RZ |
With the discovery of water on Mars does that mean there could be rainbows on Mars? | Not quite rainbows, because there is no rain, but we have seen icebows with the Pathfinder mission. -- RZ |
Thanks for doing this AMA, /u/NASAJPL!
RandomNerdGeek26 karma
No problem! I occasionally make tabled summaries for interesting AMAs. Thanks for doing this AMA as well. I'll be updating this as you answer more questions.
RandomNerdGeek20 karma
Here's a summary of the questions and answers so far. It'll be updated every three or so hours.
Part 2
Question | Answer |
---|---|
From what I've seen of the game so far, the color scheme appears pretty limited. What challenges does this present in level design (as colors are often used as subtle indicators to steer players in the right direction) and what was the rationale behind this unique style, particularly after working on a series as famously color-rich as Bioshock? | The aesthetic we have allows us to not only show a unique visual motif, but also to focus on the broad strokes of the world. This gives Echo Bluff a fresh look. But yes, it also means that we have to find ways to keep the environments varied. One of the ways we try to do this is by going bold with the architecture. I think the monochromatic look does really help make thing pop when you do see color, through things like Cassie's memories or ghosts. When you think about it, Star Wars is a very monochromatic film from shot-to-shot. Think about the Death Star. It's practically a black and white film! This makes the lightsabers and blasters pop even more. The eye craves that contrast and it helps focus on the stars of the shots. I'm not going to knock the prequels, but because everything was so colorful, you get a bit fatigued. (for the record, I love Episode III) |
Racism is a huge theme in Bioshock Infinite; did you have any concerns about how that would be received by your audience? That first violent scene on that stage was shocking to me, but I imagine it was intended to be. I felt like everything was very well done throughout the game though. | I can't speak for others, but I was certainly concerned. Our intent was never to simply shock. My understanding of the intent (again, I hate speaking for other people) was to portray a time in which that was the reality. Is it uncomfortable? Absolutely. But if games can't take on that sort of material, how can we address the issues? Isn't it one of the roles of art to shine a light on humanity - ugliness included? I think the key here is that BioShock was never meant to be exploitative. It took on difficult subjects with the intent of making people think rather than simply pushing hot-buttons. |
How many hours have you put into Perception already? Does it feel different working on your own game, as opposed to Bioshock, etc? | I started around October of last year. Hour-wise? Tough to say. I'm having so much frickin fun working on it that it's a bit of a blur. Tons? It definitely feels different than past projects in that I'm taking on so much more with it being my old company. Irrational was awesome, particularly in the early days, in that we were allowed to wear many different hats. I learned a ton, but running the business and the kickstarter is an enormous amount of work. Still, the rewards are also far greater than I imagined. I absolutely love hearing what people think and connecting directly with you folks! |
Will there be the possibility of actually tapping the screen on touchscreen devices to emulate Cassie tapping? | That would certainly be an awesome idea. Right now we're only targeting PC, PS4 and XBox One, but as an enormous Nintendo fan, I'd love to talk WiiU. If things go well, I would definitely look into it. We're still a very small team though, so I'd need to look into how much value the kind of tapping would bring to the experience. I want to make sure if we take on a challenge, gamers are going to love the result. |
Here's my question: seeing how Perception is different from the traditional horror genre, how do you think the game will be received by reviewers? Is there a game you would compare it to?
RandomNerdGeek141 karma
Here's a summary of the questions and answers so far. It'll be updated every three or so hours.
Part 1
Part 2
View HistoryShare Link