Highest Rated Comments


Malbranch152 karma

What's the worst blacksmithing snafu you've seen/witnessed/heard about/crisis controlled?

I know you haven't been at the entertainment manager role for very long, but Ren fairs aren't something you go into cold, so I'm assuming you've been around for a bit, right?

Malbranch10 karma

Nirvana Fallacy.

Just because it's not a perfect atomic solution doesn't mean that it isn't a good or even beneficial idea.

Malbranch8 karma

“no such thing as a free lunch” and “you can’t trust the government” comments

You say you don't like the idea of people getting money for nothing. What about the rich who inherit their wealth without having to work for it? Do the rich stop working just because they don't have to?

When you say you can't trust the govt, what is it you're concerned about the govt doing?

I mean... those seem to pretty directly answer the questions posed...

Malbranch2 karma

  1. Have you read the research?
  2. Do you have a level of expertise comparable to OP to be able to materially support the notion that his position is "trust ME" instead of "trust the RESEARCH and being the expert in this topic who derived those conclusions"?
  3. Do you have any post in this thread that says "disregard the shortcomings" without addressing the supporting research from other experts in the field like the IMF that are direct contradictions to the points that are being made, or the well informed perspective on the implications of the point attempting to be made? Do you have him actually "shitting all over the opposite side" or are you just taking it personally that the counters are being provided?

I'm betting "No" is a pretty big (not) spoiler.

Malbranch1 karma

gasp someone who is actively researching and examining UBI has found it to be beneficial and is arguing in support of it? Their data has lead them to a conclusion that is well supported and documented as such? But they support it, so they must be biased, so the objectivity of the supporting research is moot because someone has the audacity to have deduced the benefits and advocated for the positive effects!

"Research"

Dude, between you, me, and OP, at least 2 out of 3 of us are peer-reviewed published, and I'd bet money you're not in that club. If you were, you could take one look at the research output documented in his UoB profile page and get "real answers" without the middle man.