Highest Rated Comments


Facha66918 karma

Psychological torture is not allowed anymore under any circumstances. ICRC monitors interrogations recordings. Besides, these detainees have no further useful information. Most are still incarcerated only to prevent them from going back to fighting and because we can't do anything with them. Source: I'm a DoD interrogator.

EDIT: This is not my AMA. I wanted to clarify a bit the question posed. My job is used to prevent as much as possible attacks on US interests, land, and people. Thus, I don't want to shine too much info on the subject in such a public forum

EDIT 2: This thread has lost focus. I provided a tidbit to answer a question and more questions came in for me, which was fine at first. Then two people started attacking with opinions and even i lost focus. I apologize OP. I believe in what i do and i fight for what i believe. I will erase my negative comments that serve no purpose to the original topic.

Facha66911 karma

Not once have i made any pro torture claim. Btw, you still haven't seen anything personally.

You're an idiot. I will not entertain a troll

Facha66910 karma

I have NEVER tortured a detainee in any way. I believe that if you do, you aren't good at this job. But it is necessary to obtain information from detainees to prevent attacks, disrupt networks, stop the flow of financial ops, detain leaders, find supplies, training camps, and minimize conflict.

Facha6697 karma

Again, saying info is necessary doesn't equate to saying torture is necessary. Also, i still don't read anything from you in first count perspective so you continue to don't know what you are talking about. You are still trolling.

Facha6696 karma

What is your first count source? Have you been there? Have you talked to a detainee? What do you personally know? Khalid Shaykh Muhammad didn't know anything?

Of course not everyone was bad, but you can't justifiable make such a blanket statement.