DVDJunky

I'm gonna sound like a shill for this company, but I had similar problems as you and I actually think having the right size "fit" help keep me in the mood and not lose n erection when I put them on.

I have ZERO affiliation with MyONE other than I've purchased from them before. I DID get an email from them (because I'm on their mailing list) saying I should come check out this AMA, but that's the extent.

If I recall they have a free (or pretty close to free) sample you can get to try them out...

I'm not going to say they've changed my life, but they've made me a bit happier/safer in the bedroom.

They used to offer a three pack sampler (I got it in the past) that offered the one you measured up to, a slightly larger, and slightly smaller.

Now it looks like they offer a two pack sampler with the one you measure up to, and one slightly smaller.

The comment being referring to by /u/passinghere is asking for a larger sample size for a woman to keep for male partners so I think it's a slightly different answer. Hopefully you'll get a response from the company though as things have clearly changed for them since I last ordered. Now I've got to go figure out my "new size"...

Imperial, Balthazar, Nebuchadnezzar

Letters and numbers that correspond to length and girth.

Your comment reminded me of that Paul Rudd scene... What movie was that in?

Edit: Found it

I'm sorry I don't remember the mailers they come in. I don't recall them being INdiscreet...

I can tell you when I ordered the sampler it came in a small cardstock envelope. This is apparently the new version of that sampler.

And this is what the condoms come in when you actually order more than just the sampler.