Highest Rated Comments


Borigh12 karma

They don't have to be profound. Just so he knows who you are and how you think about things. What books do you love, which ones are overrated, which movie adaptations are great, which are rubbish.

I'm sure his mother can impart loads of wisdom: just tell him who you are. And in the effort, you'll end up making absolutely priceless documents for future archaeologists.

Borigh11 karma

Are you aware that Bush administration defense officials met former Soviet military officials that worked on their Afghan campaign before 9/11?

I’m not a conspiracy theorist: this is just evidence that, like Clinton, Bush was aware of the threat of Al Qaeda in Afghanistan before 9/11.

Has the American government substantially adjusted how they deal with non-governmental actors that might want to do us harm, both in the wake of this experience and learning from the team that did the COIN manual revision during the Iraq War?

Or in your view, do we still just ignore them until we decide to bust out the cruise missiles?

Borigh3 karma

The electoral college is a consciously anti-democratic measure, designed to prevent mob rule. I can see arguments in favor of elector systems, but since electors are essentially bound in their votes, nowadays, it doesn't serve its actual core function.

Given the almost absurd extent the senate is weighed to small-pop states, I think it's disingenuous to suggest that small-pop states would disproportionately lack political power in a popular vote system. As it is, many more votes are wasted because of the absurd margins in deep-blue and deep-red states than under any popular vote system.

Yes, Presidential candidates would spend more time campaigning in New York City than in Lancaster, PA. But I don't think they'd be spending less time in the Dakotas - they already pay no attention to any state within the swing margin. Conversely, they'd have to pay more attention to moderately large population areas in non-swing states. So Louisville, Nashville, and St. Louis, and their suburbs and surroundings would also get more attention.

If the argument is that the percentage of urban voters is so high that they'd swamp rural voters, that forces one to ask why rural voters having a disproportionate say in both the executive and legislative branches in inherently desirable, as this further leads to a disproportionate sway in the courts.

Borigh1 karma

If the disease becomes endemic, would your vaccine likely offer more, less, or the same protection, compared to traditional ones?

Borigh1 karma

How much voter fraud vs. votes wrongly disallowed do you expect in this election? How much have you seen of each in past elections?