Highest Rated Comments


BenjiMontgomery23 karma

That whites were responsible for 80 percent of what we call "suicide by cop," where a person has made suicidal statements and basically forces the police to shoot. That's an incredibly strong trend and makes me wonder what kinds of cultural ideas are at play. Welcome to ideas if anybody has them.

BenjiMontgomery16 karma

Great question, and it honestly felt like we failed to take a hard look at this, partly because there was some uncertainty about race reporting. We know that 120 of those shot were reported as Hispanic, but there were black Hispanics and white Hispanics, which is why we chose to categorize them that way. So our "black" is not only African American, and "white" is not only caucasion. If that makes sense. I hope Connie will fact check me here.

BenjiMontgomery15 karma

They've been criticized, but I think the PERF guidelines make a lot of sense. Slow down, create time and distance, don't fire into vehicles, render first aid immediately after shooting, shape policy that's more strict than what's established by SC's Graham v. Connor.

More (pdf): http://www.policeforum.org/assets/30%20guiding%20principles.pdf

The criticism is that some of them put officers at greater risk.

BenjiMontgomery15 karma

Maybe crack analyst Connie Humburg could answer this. She'ss looking in.

Resisting arrest was very high. All 827 were justifiable, according to courts. Only one of the 827 drew criminal charges, and it was thrown out of court after he claimed "stand your ground." Victim was Jermaine McBean, if you want to check it out.

BenjiMontgomery12 karma

Not flawless, necessarily, just not criminal.