Norman E. Rosenthal

n the 1980s first described winter depression or seasonal affective disorder (SAD), and pioneered the use of light therapy for its treatment.

Hosted AMAs

Highest Rated Comments

normanrosenthal710 karma

Yes, my colleagues laughed, but I am not alone in being ridiculed for a novel idea. The German philosopher Schopenhauer put it best when he said: All truth passes through three stages. First, it is ridiculed. Second, it is violently opposed. Third, it is accepted as being self-evident.

normanrosenthal501 karma

This is such a fascinating question and I don't believe I can do it justice in this format. However, it seems as though one's sexual identity and sexual preferences (same vs. other sex) are separately influenced, possibly by intrauterine hormones or by early experiences. So, one could see how you can get variations. There are clear cases of people feeling strongly that they are one or another gender from very early on. They can be psychologically healthy and well-adjusted. That cannot be said of someone who thinks he is a horse

normanrosenthal461 karma

I think it is an excellent idea, and am impressed by the latest phase 3 study of MDMA for PTSD in veterans. As long as the research is done carefully and well, with all the necessary safeguards, this is how knowledge is advanced and new treatments are developed.

normanrosenthal455 karma

Some of my best friends are introverts. Introverts are among the most thoughtful people, the best listeners and the kindest people I know. It's just that they must reach out at least a bit so that others can appreciate their wonderful qualities

normanrosenthal357 karma

Fascinating discussion. Most gay guys -- especially these days -- are OK with being gay (not that there aren't issues) but most consider themselves men. So, if someone thinks of himself as a woman there is probably something else going on rather than a denial of being gay, which has a retro Freudian feel to it (not to say it's wrong). But what a fascinating line of reasoning. Your colleagues and supervisors must enjoy your inquiring mind

normanrosenthal347 karma

What a great thread. Who could imagine that blasphemy could be so much fun?

normanrosenthal337 karma

Yes, at some point in our history, it might have been advantageous to gain weight, eat more and slow down in winter, when there little food around. Nowadays, however, when food is available all year round, these very same behaviors are disadvantageous

normanrosenthal285 karma

Oh my! You take me back to some good old days. Thanks for the memories, whoever you are!

normanrosenthal280 karma

It's a great question as to why psychiatrists don't use light therapy more. They certainly should. I think a lot has to do with economics. Drug companies spend a lot of money to "educate" doctors to prescribe drugs. Don't get me wrong. I prescribe drugs -- but usually I prescribe light first for seasonal affective disorder

normanrosenthal270 karma

I gather that Vogon poetry is very bureaucratic so it would not be my first choice as a therapeutic option.